Trending Topics

Phoenix pays $605K to settle lawsuit over patient dropped during transport

The city agreed to settle a lawsuit alleging firefighters fatally injured a 76-year-old man after dropping him while carrying him from his home

PHOENIX — Phoenix will pay $605,000 to settle a wrongful death lawsuit filed after a 76-year-old man allegedly suffered fatal injuries when firefighters dropped him while carrying him out of his home.

The Phoenix City Council unanimously approved the settlement on July 1, more than two years after the man’s death, 12News reported.

| ON-DEMAND WEBINAR: Smart tools, strategic choices: EMS puts AI into action

The lawsuit stems from a January 2024 response to Ronald Shuck’s home after he had difficulty standing. Court documents allege firefighters kept Shuck in a rolling office chair instead of moving him to a gurney, then dropped him while carrying him down outdoor steps, causing him to hit his head and back.

Shuck’s son said the fall broke his father’s neck and back, and that he later lost the ability to talk, move or eat. The lawsuit, filed on behalf of Shuck’s wife, alleged the firefighters’ negligence caused his death.

Trending
San Marcos EMS, the new department staffed largely by familiar paramedics and EMTs, joins San Marcos police and fire as the city’s third emergency service
Wake County’s program eliminates out-of-pocket costs for emergency ambulance transport within the county for enrolled households, requires existing health insurance to join, and generates about $1.1 million annually for the county’s $92 million EMS budget
Merced County’s new 911 Nurse Navigation program aims to free up ambulances for critical emergencies by directing non-life-threatening callers to urgent care, telehealth or home care options instead
Josh Law spent two hours alone in rough Pacific waters off Baja California, personally pulling 16 survivors to safety using the “buddy tow” technique, while 11 others were never found despite an 89-hour search

Bill Carey is the associate editor for FireRescue1.com and EMS1.com. A former Maryland volunteer firefighter, sergeant, and lieutenant, Bill has written for several fire service publications and platforms. His work on firefighter behavioral health garnered a 2014 Neal Award nomination. His ongoing research and writings about line-of-duty death data is frequently cited in articles, presentations, and trainings. Have a news tip? He can be reached at news@lexipol.com.