Trending Topics

Family sues AMR after N.Y. man dies after being removed from ambulance

Video showed Rochester police and AMR leaving the man on a bench where he fell over and was unattended for more than two minutes, the lawsuit claims

By Bill Carey
EMS1

ROCHESTER, N.Y. — A newly filed lawsuit claims that the City of Rochester and the ambulance company American Medical Response (AMR) failed to provide medical care to a Rochester man, resulting in his death.

On Nov. 30, Julian Coleman was in an AMR ambulance on the way to the hospital when EMS personnel called Rochester police to have him removed after he assaulted a crew member, WHAM reported.


EMS personnel reportedly called Rochester police to have the man removed after he assaulted a crewmember

WHEC reports that the lawsuit claims AMR personnel and Rochester Police officers violated Coleman’s civil rights. Two EMTs and two officers are named in the lawsuit.

Coleman had called 911 because he could not breathe. Inside the ambulance, he panicked and grabbed one of the EMS providers, prompting a call to the police to have him removed.

The video shows Coleman collapsing moments after getting out of the ambulance on Seneca Avenue. He lay face-down on the sidewalk for nearly two and a half minutes before anyone helped him. The lawsuit claims his brain had already been deprived of oxygen, WHEC reported.

Coleman was eventually taken back to the hospital, where he never regained consciousness. He died two weeks later due to an anoxic brain injury, according to WHEC. He had been on a respirator in intensive care and was taken off life support on Dec. 15.


A New York man collapsed on a sidewalk after police ordered him to exit an ambulance where he is alleged to have assaulted an EMS provider

“We feel extremely confident that the medicine is very straightforward here that he died because he was deprived of oxygen. If he had been given oxygen in the ambulance, he never would have even lost consciousness,” Stephen Schwarz, the lawyer for the family, said. “This is not an uncommon thing that they have to deal with, they’re trained. The training is not to set people out on the street and have them die.”

One of the EMTs was fired. The city and AMR have declined to comment.


Trending
Video from the scene shows the man, who was holding a knife in each hand, advancing toward Buffalo Police officers, prompting the fatal shooting
Dispatchers say smartphone location programs such as RapidSOS and what3words help them find callers with near-constant accuracy
Factoryville officials voiced support for local ambulance service and approved a letter backing a proposed $500,000 federal grant aimed at helping EMS agencies across Wyoming County
Bi-County Ambulance marked its 50th anniversary with a ceremony honoring its history, founder and ongoing investments