By Michael K. Anderson and Ron Gill
The fire service is built upon crises, alarms, EMS calls, rescues and major incident responses, requiring personnel to operate under a lot of stress and pressure. While firefighters and EMS professionals are extensively trained to handle these types of emergencies affecting others, many leaders receive little-to-no formal training in managing crises that directly affect their own organizations.
Firefighters can put out a building on fire, stabilize a patient or contain a hazardous spill. But when it comes to a crisis within an organization, things get a lot more complicated. These kinds of crises are often deeply entrenched and can possess wide-ranging consequences, making them much harder to resolve than a straightforward emergency.
Line-of-duty deaths, firefighter suicides, catastrophic vehicle collisions, active shooter incidents, allegations of misconduct, social media scandals, budget reductions, labor disputes, litigation, workplace violence, natural disasters and political controversies can threaten the stability of an agency within hours.
The true test of leadership is not how effectively a chief officer manages routine operations. The true test occurs when the organization encounters uncertainty, fear, public scrutiny and quickly changing circumstances.
In those moments, firefighters and EMS personnel aren’t searching for flawless decisions. What they really need is someone to take charge and lead them through the situation.
| MORE: Presilience in EMS leadership: Beyond bouncing back
Understanding crisis leadership
Crisis leadership differs significantly from routine management.
Management focuses on processes, systems, schedules, budgets and daily operations. Leadership during a crisis focuses on people.
During a crisis, personnel want answers to four fundamental questions:
- What happened?
- What are we doing about it?
- Am I safe?
- Can I trust my leaders?
When leaders fail to answer those questions, uncertainty fills the void. Rumors begin spreading. Morale deteriorates. Public faith erodes, and a leader’s responsibility is not to eliminate uncertainty immediately. The responsibility is to provide stability while handling uncertainty.
The first rule: Control yourself first
Before leaders can stabilize an organization, they must stabilize themselves. Personnel carefully observe leaders during stressful situations. They evaluate every statement, facial expression and decision. If a chief officer appears overwhelmed, emotional, disorganized or indecisive, personnel often assume the situation is worse than it actually is. Leaders must have the trust of their people; effective crisis leaders maintain emotional discipline. This does not mean leaders lack emotion. It means they do not allow emotions to control decision-making.
The ability to keep collected under pressure is contagious. Just as panic spreads through an organization, so does confidence. Often during command transition, rapid changes result in reorganization that must be communicated. Personnel take cues from leadership; if leaders remain composed; the organization is more likely to keep composed.
Establish situational awareness
One of the greatest mistakes leaders make during a crisis is acting on insufficient information.
Social media, news reports, radio traffic, witness statements and rumors often provide conflicting information during the early stages of an event.
Effective leaders gather information before making major decisions.
Key questions include:
- What do we actually know?
- What do we think we know?
- What remains unknown?
- What assumptions are being made?
- What information can be independently verified?
The phrase “I don’t know yet” is often more credible than providing inaccurate information.
Personnel and the public are generally forgiving about delayed answers.
They are far less forgiving of incorrect answers.
Communication: The most powerful leadership tool
During a crisis, communication becomes operationally critical. Personnel often become frustrated not because information is unavailable, but because information is absent. When communication stops, speculation begins.
Leaders should communicate:
- Early
- Frequently
- Honestly
- Consistently
This applies internally and externally. A common leadership mistake is waiting until all information becomes available before communicating. In reality, personnel often need updates even when little has changed, and a simple statement such as: “we’re currently looking into what’s happening, but we don’t have all the details yet,” or “as soon as we get more information, we’ll let you know what’s going on,” can markedly reduce anxiety and uncertainty.
Decision-making under pressure
Crises often force leaders to make decisions with incomplete information. Waiting for perfect information can be as dangerous as making reckless decisions. Effective crisis leaders understand that decisions can often be adjusted as additional information becomes available. The objective is not perfection but reasonable, knowledgeable action.
Leaders should ask:
- What is the immediate threat?
- What is the worst-case outcome?
- What action reduces risk?
- What resources are available?
- When will the requested resources be on scene?
- What are the legal and operational consequences?
Decisiveness builds confidence. Indecision creates chaos.
Leading through line-of-duty deaths
Few events test leadership more than a firefighter or EMS line-of-duty death.
These incidents create operational, emotional, political, legal and media challenges simultaneously. Personnel experience grief, anger, guilt, fear and confusion. Leaders must balance compassion with business continuity.
Key priorities include:
- Supporting the family
- Assisting affected personnel
- Preserving investigative integrity
- Working with outside agencies
- Continuing operational preparedness
- Managing media inquiries
- Designating a public information officer (PIO)
Leaders must recognize that recovery is measured in months and years — not days. The organization may never fully return to what it was before.
| MORE: Quick Take: Planning for a line of duty death
Crisis leadership throughout critical incidents
Mass casualty incidents, active shooter events, natural disasters and large-scale emergencies require leaders to function strategically. Operational leaders often become consumed by immediate tactical concerns. Crisis leaders maintain a wider perspective.
They must simultaneously consider:
- Personnel accountability
- Resource assignment
- Mutual aid coordination
- Designated staging area with an assigned manager
- Public messaging
- Political implications
- Family notifications
- Long-term recovery
The incident itself may end within hours, and consequences may last for years.
The social media challenge
Modern crises unfold in real time even before the people in charge get there; regular people are already sharing pictures, videos and their thoughts on social media, and some are even making accusations. Information spreads globally within minutes, and leaders who ignore social media surrender the narrative to others. Does your organization have a social media policy? This does not mean engaging in arguments or speculation. It means providing accurate, timely information by approved channels. Transparency creates trust and silence often creates suspicion.
The human side of leadership
The greatest mistake leaders make during crises is focusing exclusively on operations while neglecting people. Personnel may appear professional on the surface while having emotional difficulties. Firefighters and EMS providers often witness traumatic events repeatedly.
Crisis leaders must ensure staff has access to:
- Peer support teams
- Critical incident stress management resources
- Mental health professionals
- Chaplain services
- Employee assistance programs
Strong leaders understand that emotional recovery is an operational issue and healthy personnel make better decisions.
Building enterprise resilience
The best crisis leaders prepare before a crisis occurs.
Preparation includes:
- Leadership development programs
- Succession planning
- Crisis communication plans
- Media training
- Tabletop exercises
- Policy reviews
- Mutual aid partnerships
Organizations that train for crisis leadership before disaster strikes regularly outperform those that attempt to improvise under pressure. Resilience is not created during the crisis; it is revealed during the crisis.
Lessons from the fireground
The principles that make effective incident commanders also make effective crisis leaders:
- Size-up
- Maintain situational awareness
- Communicate clearly
- Order all anticipated resources early in the incident
- Use available resources
- Adjust to changing conditions
- Protect your people
- Remain calm
- Lead by example
These principles are just as important when dealing with a big fire, a serious medical emergency, the death of a firefighter on the job, a lawsuit, a problem on social media or a disaster that hurts the public’s image of us.
The true test of leadership
At some point, every person in charge of a fire department, ambulance team or other emergency organization will have to deal with a really tough situation that tests their skills, personality and judgment. This can be a big test, and it’s how they handle it that really matters. It’s not a matter of if a crisis will happen, but when. The question is whether leaders are prepared when it does. Personnel rarely remember every tactical decision made during a crisis. They do remember how leaders treated people, how they conveyed messages and whether they inspired confidence when confidence was most needed. Crisis leadership is not about possessing all the answers; it is about developing a command team. It is about delivering stability when others feel uncertainty, direction when others feel confusion and hope when circumstances appear overwhelming.
The true test of leadership is not how effectively a chief officer manages routine operations. The true test occurs when the organization confronts uncertainty, fear, public scrutiny and quickly changing circumstances.
In those moments, firefighters and EMS personnel aren’t searching for flawless decisions. What they really need is someone to take charge and lead them through the situation.
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Michael K. Anderson is a nationally recognized fire and EMS legal expert, instructor and published author with 40 years of operational, command, training and leadership experience. He provides nationwide litigation support and expert analysis in fire operations, EMS standard of care, emergency vehicle operations and incident command.
Ron Gill brings 45 years of manufacturing experience, including 30 as a production engineer and technical fellow at Boeing. He served as a Riverside County volunteer firefighter from 1981 to 1987, rising to apparatus engineer, and from 2001 to 2007 worked in special operations on the department’s Mobile Emergency Operations Center, retiring as a unit lieutenant. He holds an MBA from UC Irvine and studied organizational leadership at Pepperdine.
REFERENCES
- Clement J. “On Cancel Culture: Silence Has No Future.” Medium.
- Andrechek D. “What Strong Organizations Build Before They Need It: Why Resilience Is Created Long Before It Is Tested.” LinkedIn.
- Thomas M. “Leadership Communication During Crisis: How Great Leaders Build Trust When Uncertainty Peaks.” mathewthomas.in.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. “Crisis and Emergency Risk Communications (CERC): Radiation Emergencies.” CDC.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. “Crisis & Emergency Risk Communication (CERC).” CDC.