Trending Topics

Ohio EMS provider, Uber incident highlights EMS legal, certification issues

A Lynx EMS provider allegedly left a chest-pain patient to take an Uber. Prosecutors say criminal charges depend on harm, but certification discipline can range from a reprimand to revocation

Driver of private Ohio ambulance service accused of abandoning patient, calling Uber home.jpg

A Lynx EMS ambulance.

Lynx EMS|Facebook

By Lizzie Kaboski
cleveland.com

CLEVELAND — Lema Tackett was already hurting and anxious when the private ambulance carrying her from Toledo to Cleveland Clinic’s Main Campus pulled into a gas station on Cleveland’s West Side.

The 56-year-old was recovering from surgery and experiencing chest and back pain. Then she said she heard the ambulance driver say something she never expected to hear:

“I’m Ubering back to Toledo.”

| EARLIER: Driver of private Ohio ambulance service accused of abandoning patient, calling Uber home

Her account is backed up by a Cleveland Fire run report, which says Cleveland EMS arrived five minutes later for the Oct. 28 call, finding Tackett’s stress surging. First responders gave her aspirin and oxygen and loaded her onto a new truck.

The first ambulance was operated by Lynx EMS, a company whose driver — according to Tackett — said her shift was over.

But is dumping a patient in need of emergency services illegal? Ohio law, specifically pieces of section 2903, leaves it in a gray area.

State law says caretakers must provide care to people they know are functionally impaired if that person might suffer physical harm without it.

Yet there are several things that legally make someone a caretaker: They volunteer to provide care, are paid for it, are related to the patient or have been court-ordered to provide care.

Cuyahoga County assistant prosecutors Terese McKenna and Andrew Rogalski said a medic could fall under the caretaking definition within the statute.

To indict and prosecute this, however, it requires that the victim suffered physical harm as a result of the caretaker’s actions. If it resulted in what the statute called “serious harm,” like a life-threatening injury or even death, it could be prosecuted as a felony.

McKenna said a prosecutor would need to present testimony from a medical professional to confirm the kind of harm that was sustained as a result of the caretaker’s actions.

“Their condition would need to get worse as a result of the delay,” she said. “If the person couldn’t receive medical care because of the abandonment or delay, that could result in more serious charges.”

Rogalski said the cases are fact-specific. They’d look at how long the person was without medical care and whether they experienced a medical event as a result of the driver leaving or couldn’t get the care they needed in time. In cases like this, they might ask an outside agency or expert to review the case.

“The harm drives our decision-making process,” Rogalski said. “With criminal law, you’re stuck using the statutes that are out there. If you wanted something more specific, you’d need the legislature to act.”

Whether the driver qualified as a caretaker is unclear. What isn’t is that the dropoff was unethical, according to Ohio professional conduct laws.

According to Ohio’s administrative rules for EMS professionals, they have a responsibility to provide professional services that meet the minimum standards of care for their certification level, provide medically appropriate evaluation, treatment and disposition of each EMS patient, follow state laws, administrative rules and their EMS organization’s medical protocols, ensure patient care is accurately documented and not knowingly transfer patient care or delegate EMS functions to someone who lacks the appropriate certification and training.

“It is unethical to abandon a patient that is in your care,” Cleveland Association of Rescue Employees President Mark Barrett said. “Paramedics are required to transfer care to an equal or higher-level provider.”

The State Board of Emergency Medical, Fire and Transportation Services can take disciplinary action against someone holding an EMS certificate for violating state EMS laws or regulations, including professional standards of conduct. It could carry civil penalties, such as in a medical malpractice, negligence, or breach-of-contract lawsuit. Depending on the circumstances, a person could face charges of reckless endangerment or patient neglect.

Natalie Everetts, public information officer with the Ohio Department of Public Safety, said the state’s Division of EMS is aware of the incident. She said investigative proceedings are confidential until they are completed.

Barrett said that he does not know if any laws were broken, but the state board could pull a paramedic’s or EMT’s license if they find out that any professional conduct rules were broken.

Potential disciplinary actions include the suspension of an EMS certificate, revocation of an EMS certificate, restrictions or limitations on a certificate, a written reprimand, a fine of up to $1,000 and a refusal to renew or issue a certificate.

Tackett said the ambulance driver may have been lost when she pulled off the road.

For Barrett, regardless of the reason, there’s no excuse.

“I find it hard to believe that the medic was lost with the current tech and the fact they could figure out how to contact an Uber,” Barrett said. “If they were tired and nearing the end of their shift while not being able to drive, they could have done anything other than abandoning their patient.”

The driver was not a member of Cleveland EMS or the Cleveland Association of Rescue Employee group.

Tackett said she believes the person who was driving the ambulance is indeed a paramedic. There was another paramedic who was seated in the back of the vehicle with her during the transport.

A person who is not EMS-certified can drive an ambulance under certain circumstances, provided the ambulance has the required certified personnel aboard and the driver has completed the required emergency vehicle operator course.

When asked for an update, Lynx EMS said the safety and quality care “are of the utmost importance to us and responsibilities we take very seriously.” They said they are continuing to review the circumstances surrounding the incident and that “immediate steps were taken to address the matter and ensure the patient’s well-being and care needs were addressed,” although they did not say what those were.

“As this involves personnel and patient-related matters, we are unable to comment further,” a company spokesperson said.

Trending
Utica Fire & Rescue created its own EMS service after New Chapel EMS was ousted from the district, launching operations Nov. 16 with about 50 trained volunteers, including 15 EMTs and seven paramedics
Grant County Fire District 7’s Proposition No. 1, which would double the EMS levy rate and generate an estimated $250,000 annually, led 59.47% to 40.53%, securing four full-time positions as call volumes rise and a federal SAFER grant nears expiration
The half-cent tax increase, passed 54% to 46%, will generate about $345 million annually to hire more firefighters and paramedics, repair stations and open new ones, as the department works to cut average response times currently near eight minutes
Virginia Tech’s Board of Visitors approved a $16M facility for its student-run rescue squad, with construction starting next year and completion targeted for 2028

©2026 Advance Local Media LLC.
Visit cleveland.com.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.