Trending Topics

Data versus Darwin with Todd Stout

Surviving the AI gold rush in EMS

AI may feel like the newest revolution in EMS, but the industry’s relationship with data has been evolving for decades. In this episode of EMS One-Stop, Rob Lawrence sits down with FirstWatch founder Todd Stout, whose 28 years working with EMS data gives him a particularly long view of where the industry has been and where it is heading.

Todd traces the journey from an era when monthly reports printed on green-bar paper were considered normal, to today’s world of real-time dashboards, cloud-based systems and enormous volumes of operational and clinical information. The challenge has changed: EMS no longer suffers primarily from a lack of data; leaders now need technology that can identify what matters, separate signal from noise and turn information into decisions.

That makes AI extraordinarily promising — and potentially dangerous. Todd explains why he is more excited about the next 3-5 years than at any point in his career, while simultaneously being more concerned about the next 8-10 months. Rob and Todd discuss unreliable AI outputs, data security, HIPAA and privacy, the risks associated with startups and what EMS leaders should ask before entrusting vendors with organizational or patient data. They also examine the urgent need for EMS agencies to establish AI policies and train their workforce on responsible use.

Todd concludes with a preview of FirstWatch’s next generation of AI-enabled tools and a broader message for EMS leaders: the organizations that thrive through this technology shift will not necessarily be those with the newest technology, but those capable of adapting, learning and using it responsibly.

Additional resources:

Memorable quotes

  • “I’m more excited about the next 3-5 years than I’ve ever been, I am also more scared about the next 8-10 months for our industry than I’ve ever been because it’s so messy.” — Todd Stout
  • “Nobody gets into EMS to be excellent data enterers.” — Todd Stout
  • “AI well formed — with the proper bumpers, guidelines, rules around it — is astonishingly good at processing through lots of data.” — Todd Stout
  • “If you’re not paying for the thing that you’re using, you are the product.” — Todd Stout
  • “AI to many people seems like magic. And it’s the opposite of magic almost. It’s a lot of work and plumbing to get it right.” — Todd Stout

Episode timeline

  • 00:27 – Rob introduces the episode and the evolution of EMS data, information and AI
  • 01:54 – Twenty-eight years of FirstWatch: from Stout Solutions to today’s real-time data environment
  • 03:57 – Looking back at EMS’s early adoption of real-time operational data
  • 05:18 – Why immediate data can improve individual performance and expose problems with systems and protocols
  • 06:24 – The “ah, buts:" gut instinct versus what the data actually shows
  • 07:19 – Dirty data, disconnected systems and why organizations sometimes don’t believe their own numbers
  • 09:45 – EMS has moved from too little information to information overload
  • 10:31 – How AI can sift through enormous amounts of data and identify what leaders actually need to know
  • 11:22 – The accuracy problem: AI can produce impressive outputs while struggling with surprisingly basic tasks
  • 12:39 – Todd explains why he is simultaneously excited and concerned about the immediate future of AI in EMS
  • 14:35 – How EMS leaders can become better, more discerning customers of AI technology
  • 15:10 – Established technology partners versus innovative AI startups
  • 17:00 – What happens to your organization’s data if an AI vendor fails or goes out of business?
  • 17:41 – HIPAA, privacy, cybersecurity and employee data obligations
  • 18:11 – Sponsor break
  • 19:26 – Part two: protecting patient and organizational information when using AI
  • 20:18 – AI training models, data sharing and why leaders need to understand vendors’ default settings
  • 22:44 – The pace of change: today’s AI expertise can become outdated within weeks
  • 23:08 – Preparing for the wave of “AI everything” appearing in EMS exhibit halls
  • 23:45 – Questions EMS leaders should ask prospective AI vendors
  • 25:20 – Why AI isn’t magic — and why implementation requires significant work behind the scenes
  • 27:08 – The case for every EMS organization having an AI policy now
  • 27:41 – Todd warns that employees are almost certainly already using AI, sometimes without understanding the privacy implications
  • 28:21 – Why AI education should resemble cybersecurity education: policy, training, suspicion and continual reinforcement
  • 30:13 – Preview of FirstWatch Collaborate and the company’s next generation of technology
  • 31:02 – FirstWatch 2.0, AI-enabled mobile tools and workload management
  • 31:55 – Reflect: incorporating patient satisfaction alongside operational and clinical performance
  • 33:34 – Why rapid patient feedback can be more meaningful to crews than retrospective monthly scores
  • 35:19 – Todd’s closing message: EMS is good at adapting and improvising, and technology can make the job easier
  • 36:22 – Rob’s takeaway: adapt, innovate, become a discerning AI customer and establish an organizational AI policy

Rate and review the EMS One-Stop podcast

Enjoying the show? Please take a moment to rate and review us on Apple Podcasts. Contact the EMS One-Stop team at editor@EMS1.com to share ideas, suggestions and feedback.
Listen on Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, Spotify and RSS feed.

Previously on EMS One-Stop
Liz Harney’s journey from patient to paramedic shows how empathy can change a life — and why EMS educators and leaders must treat the affective domain as seriously as clinical skills

Rob Lawrence has been a leader in civilian and military EMS for over a quarter of a century. He is currently the director of strategic implementation for PRO EMS and its educational arm, Prodigy EMS, in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and part-time executive director of the California Ambulance Association.

He previously served as the chief operating officer of the Richmond Ambulance Authority (Virginia), which won both state and national EMS Agency of the Year awards during his 10-year tenure. Additionally, he served as COO for Paramedics Plus in Alameda County, California.

Prior to emigrating to the U.S. in 2008, Rob served as the COO for the East of England Ambulance Service in Suffolk County, England, and as the executive director of operations and service development for the East Anglian Ambulance NHS Trust. Rob is a former Army officer and graduate of the UK’s Royal Military Academy Sandhurst and served worldwide in a 20-year military career encompassing many prehospital and evacuation leadership roles.

Rob is the President of the Academy of International Mobile Healthcare Integration (AIMHI) and former Board Member of the American Ambulance Association. He writes and podcasts for EMS1 and is a member of the EMS1 Editorial Advisory Board. Connect with him on Twitter.