Trending Topics

Philadelphia family files lawsuit over EMS failing to aid father after unanswered knock

The lawsuit alleges EMS workers left without helping a man who had called for emergency aid — only for his son to find him dead the next day

PHILADELPHIA — A man is suing the city of Philadelphia, claiming EMS workers failed to render aid to his father, who was later found dead in his apartment after calling for help.

The lawsuit, filed by the family of 57-year-old Robert Santiago, alleges that around 3 a.m. on April 24, 2023, Santiago suffered a medical emergency in his home and pressed his MedScope America emergency alert button, FOX 29 reported. Two EMS workers reportedly responded but left after knocking lightly and receiving no answer.

“It looked like it was two girls just hanging out in the ambulance like late night,” neighbor Mariem Chakir said. “So they go to the door, they just knock very lightly three times, that’s it.”

Chakir says she directed the EMS crew to Santiago’s door, but surveillance video provided by the family’s attorney appears to show them leaving without making further effort to enter.

Santiago’s body was found the next day by his son, who said he discovered him in a state of rigor mortis, still clutching the emergency alert button.

At a news conference, the family’s attorney called for an investigation into EMS response procedures, especially in cases where there’s no answer at the door.

The city declined to comment, citing pending litigation. A source familiar with EMS operations told FOX 29 that responders typically contact dispatch to coordinate with the alert company and have the patient open the door.


Lt. Nelson Seto called 911 reporting breathing trouble, but EMTs left when he didn’t answer the door; hours later, he was found dead
Trending
An FDNY tower ladder responding to an emergency collided with a commercial van in Brooklyn, setting off a chain-reaction crash involving an Access-a-Ride bus and an SUV
After months of delays tied to federal labor rules, employees at North Huntingdon EMS/Rescue voted to remove Teamsters Local 205 as their bargaining representative
Authorities say an armed man rammed a vehicle into Temple Israel in West Bloomfield Township before being fatally shot by security
A bill that would let unions negotiate earlier retirement and higher pension caps for newly hired public safety workers is drawing support from labor groups and warnings from local governments over rising costs

Bill Carey is the associate editor for FireRescue1.com and EMS1.com. A former Maryland volunteer firefighter, sergeant, and lieutenant, Bill has written for several fire service publications and platforms. His work on firefighter behavioral health garnered a 2014 Neal Award nomination. His ongoing research and writings about line-of-duty death data is frequently cited in articles, presentations, and trainings. Have a news tip? He can be reached at news@lexipol.com.