Trending Topics

Response interval histograms for EMS calls

The big advantage of the histogram is that it allows you to visualize the distribution of all of the response interval data

In part one, we described several common measures for examining how quickly an EMS system is responding to calls — target response intervals (TRI), averages, 90th fractiles, and the percentage of compliance in meeting a target response interval.

In this column, we show you how to look at response interval information in a specialized bar chart format called a histogram.

A response interval histogram shows how many calls fall into adjacent but non-overlapping time frames. The number of calls that fall into each time frame is shown by the height of a bar. The more calls that fall into a time frame, the taller the bar will be.

Figure 1 shows all 44,229 lights and sirens responses (without cancellations or downgrades) for an EMS system for an entire year in a response interval histogram format. Each bar in Figure 1 represents a consecutive 60 second (1 minute) time frame.

The height of the first bar shows how many responses occurred within a 0 to 60 second time frame (the actual number is shown in small text right above each bar — 279 responses arrived in 60 seconds or less).

The next bar is for a 61 to 120 second time frame, as so on — all the way out to 3600 seconds (60 minutes).

1216-hist-1-small.jpg

Figure 1 – Response interval histogram in 60 second time frame increments.

Figure 2 and 3 show the same data, but use 240 second (4 minute) and 480 second (8 minute) time frames, respectively. You can make the time frames as narrow or wide as desired — it just depends on how much detail you would like to have in the graph.

1216-hist-2-small.jpg

Figure 2 – Response interval histogram in 240 second (4 minute) time frame increments

12216-hist-3-small.jpg

Figure 3 – Response interval histogram in 480 second (8 minute) time frame increments

The big advantage of the histogram is that it allows you to visualize the distribution of all of the response interval data.

Notice in Figure 2 that the height of the bars tapers off as you get past the peak in the 240 to 480 second (4 – 8 min.) time frame. However, there are still some lights and sirens calls that are taking a very long time to arrive. Some calls are still showing up after the 1200 second (20 min.) time frame.

This system had a target response interval (TRI) of 12 minutes. The data shows that 86 percent of their calls complied with that TRI. The 90th fractile for this data falls between the 13 and 14 minute bars.

There were eight calls that took between 3120 and 3600 seconds (52 to 60 minutes) to arrive! You do not want to risk missing that kind of important information by just looking at the percent of compliance to the TRI or the 90th fractile value.

The response interval histogram is a powerful data visualization tool that let’s you see what ALL of your response interval data looks like so you don’t overlook important details. It should be included in all of your standard response interval performance reports.

Mic Gunderson has been involved in emergency healthcare for over 40 years in various leadership, managerial and clinical roles. Currently, he is the President of the Center for Systems Improvement. Prior positions include – National Director, Clinical Systems, American Heart Association; Executive Director, Kent County (MI) EMS; President, Integral Performance Solutions; National Director for Quality, Education and Research, Rural/Metro Corporation; Director of Research and Education, Office of the Medical Director, Pinellas County (FL) EMS; and as a Research Associate, Department of Surgery, University of South Florida College of Medicine, Tampa, FL. Email him at Mic@ImproveTheSystem.com.

Before taking on the role of CEO at Integral Performance Solutions, Todd Hatley was the Chief Operating Officer of HealthAnalytics. Prior to that, he was an Adjunct Assistant Professor in the Department of Emergency Medicine at the University of North Carolina. Todd’s formal education includes an Associate degree in EMS, Bachelors degree in Business Administration and dual Masters Degrees in Business Administration and Healthcare Administration.