Trending Topics

Rob on the Road: Understanding the business of buying

An 8-step checklist for evaluating equipment and vehicle purchases — from first vendor call to signed contract

Geometric EMS balance scale scene.png

Image/AI

This edition of Rob on the Road comes from the Kentucky EMS LINKS (Leadership in Kentucky) Leadership & Networking Event, where a session from Dione Amirkhan on contract negotiations caught my attention for a very simple reason: we spend a great deal of time teaching people how to lead EMS organizations, but remarkably little teaching them how to buy for them. Then we give those same leaders authority to spend serious money.

Ambulances now routinely cost a quarter of a million dollars or more. Add cardiac monitors, stretchers, ventilators, communications equipment, software and service contracts and even a relatively small EMS organization can quickly be making purchasing decisions measured in hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Yet purchasing is often a skill acquired by experience rather than taught deliberately.

That was what made this session so useful. Amirkhan brought experience from the vendor side of EMS as well as an understanding of the operational environment. The result wasn’t a lesson in beating up suppliers for the lowest possible price. It was something much more valuable: how to become an informed purchaser and create a process that produces the best overall value.

Fill out the form on this page to download your copy of “Buy smarter: An EMS checklist for evaluating equipment and vehicle purchases”

Start with the need

The first lesson should probably be written above the desk of anyone about to make a major purchase: start with the need, not the brand.

EMS is naturally susceptible to familiarity. We’ve used the same monitor for years. Everybody knows the stretcher. Our neighboring service uses a particular ventilator. We’ve always bought our ambulances from the same manufacturer. There may be perfectly good reasons to buy the same product again. But make that the conclusion of the process, not the starting point. Instead, begin by defining the problem. What are we trying to achieve? What works with our current equipment? What doesn’t? What is clinically or operationally essential? What might we need five years from now?
Only then should we start looking at products.

That leads directly to competition. A competitive process isn’t about creating an adversarial relationship with vendors. Good vendor relationships are enormously important in EMS. Competition simply ensures that the organization has genuinely examined its options and gives suppliers an opportunity to demonstrate their best combination of product, support and price.

Do your homework

And before making that first vendor call, do some homework.

  • What did we pay last time?
  • What are comparable services paying?
  • What state, local or cooperative purchasing contracts exist?
  • What are other agencies experiencing with the equipment we’re considering?

The EMS grapevine can be a remarkably effective procurement tool. Call several chiefs who already own the product. Ask what works. Ask what doesn’t. Ask about reliability, service and support after the sale. The specification sheet tells you what the product should do. An organization that has used 20 of them every day for four years can tell you what ownership is actually like.

Then make sure you’re comparing the same thing. A lower quotation means very little if one proposal includes training, accessories and an extended warranty while another doesn’t. Establish what comes as standard, what your organization requires and what is optional. Ask competing vendors to price against the same requirements.

Calculate ownership cost

But perhaps my biggest takeaway from the session was this: stop thinking about purchase price and start thinking about ownership cost.

Amirkhan illustrated this using a 12-ventilator purchase. One option cost $172,000, another $178,000 and the third $185,000. Easy decision? Not when the five-year costs were calculated.

The $172,000 option became $239,000. The $178,000 option became $218,000. And the supposedly expensive $185,000 option ultimately cost $207,000. The apparent cheapest and most expensive products had changed places.

That’s a $45,000 swing in the purchasing decision depending upon whether the leader looks at the number on today’s purchase order or what the organization will actually spend. Batteries, consumables, servicing, software, maintenance, accessories, replacement components and warranties all add up. So perhaps the most useful question to take home from Kentucky is simply: What will this cost us over five years?

The same broader thinking should apply to negotiation. Price matters, but so do warranty, training, service, delivery, accessories, financing and future pricing. Sometimes a supplier may have limited ability to move further on acquisition price, but considerably more flexibility elsewhere.

Plan for the future

Timing matters too. Vendors and manufacturers operate to their own business cycles, just as we do. Understanding those cycles and planning a purchase well in advance can create opportunities. Likewise, volume has value, and smaller EMS organizations shouldn’t automatically assume they don’t have any. If neighboring services are replacing similar equipment at roughly the same time, collaboration may create purchasing power that none possesses individually.

There was also an important warning about the future. Long-term purchasing arrangements can offer predictability and convenience, but leaders need to understand exactly what they are committing their organization to. A deal that extends through several equipment replacement cycles deserves particular scrutiny because today’s leadership may effectively be choosing tomorrow’s product before that product even exists.

This is where purchasing becomes much more than negotiation. It becomes governance. Amirkhan shared a useful concept: the weighted bid scorecard. Rather than allowing price or familiarity to dominate, the organization can determine in advance how much importance it will place on clinical fit, total cost, reliability, service and support, warranty and previous vendor performance.

The precise percentages matter less than the discipline.

Because when the process is finished, somebody should be able to look at the file without having attended a single meeting and understand exactly why the organization made the decision it did.

That’s particularly important when the purchase involves a $300,000 ambulance or a multimillion-dollar fleet replacement. Here was our need. Here were our requirements. Here were the options. Here were the costs. Here was our evaluation. And here is why we chose this solution. That’s a defensible purchasing decision.

And once it is made, there is another piece of good leadership practice worth remembering: look after the relationships with those who didn’t win. Let participating vendors know the outcome and, where appropriate, provide useful feedback. Today’s unsuccessful supplier may offer exactly what you need next time around.

My takeaway from Kentucky EMS LINKS is that purchasing deserves to be regarded as an EMS leadership competency in its own right. We are custodians of somebody else’s money. Whether those dollars ultimately come from taxpayers, patients, insurers, municipalities, healthcare systems or shareholders, we have a responsibility to spend them intelligently. Do the research. Create genuine competition. Understand the total cost. Negotiate the whole package. Think about tomorrow as well as today. Document the decision.

The people supplying our industry understand their business. We need to understand the business of buying just as well.

Fill out the form on this page to download a checklist for evaluating equipment and vehicle purchases.

Rob Lawrence has been a leader in civilian and military EMS for over a quarter of a century. He is currently the director of strategic implementation for PRO EMS and its educational arm, Prodigy EMS, in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and part-time executive director of the California Ambulance Association.

He previously served as the chief operating officer of the Richmond Ambulance Authority (Virginia), which won both state and national EMS Agency of the Year awards during his 10-year tenure. Additionally, he served as COO for Paramedics Plus in Alameda County, California.

Prior to emigrating to the U.S. in 2008, Rob served as the COO for the East of England Ambulance Service in Suffolk County, England, and as the executive director of operations and service development for the East Anglian Ambulance NHS Trust. Rob is a former Army officer and graduate of the UK’s Royal Military Academy Sandhurst and served worldwide in a 20-year military career encompassing many prehospital and evacuation leadership roles.

Rob is the President of the Academy of International Mobile Healthcare Integration (AIMHI) and former Board Member of the American Ambulance Association. He writes and podcasts for EMS1 and is a member of the EMS1 Editorial Advisory Board. Connect with him on Twitter.