The Thomas Theorem: Frontline Response to Excited Delirium
The Thomas Theorem is a fundamental law of sociology that can assist first responder personnel in their interactions with subjects experiencing excited delirium as well as mental illness.
The Theorem states that if an individual believes his situation to be real, the consequences of that belief will determine his response (Thomas & Thomas, 1928). In other words if the subject believes Elvis is coming for dinner you can expect to be asked to provide crowd control. Likewise, if the subject believes he is in immediate peril, he may behave as though his death is imminent.
People with acute mental illness (and those experiencing excited delirium) will not appreciate that their thoughts and beliefs are unusual, let alone unreal. Some subjects firmly believe what their mind is telling them — their food is poisoned; there is smoke coming from the basement; a “hit man” is hunting for them. Their disconnect with reality is going to be difficult, if not impossible for a uniformed first responder to resolve without guidance and/or training.
A quick review of excited delirium indicators is in order. These indicators can include combinations of the following:
A Beautiful Mind,
Raiders of the Lost Arkperceived
This is likely how other features of excited delirium factor into the situation. People who believe they are about to be harmed or believe they are in danger can produce unexpected physical strength due to the sudden adrenalin rush that accompanies the fight-or-flight response.
The sudden onset of paranoia could be due to misinterpretation of the events and/or hallucinations. These altered perceptions could explain the panic, shouting, and ultimately the violence displayed by subjects experiencing excited delirium. So, when you interact with a person in crisis, maintain a safe distance and listen to what they say.
It's critical to understand the distorted cognition behind a subject's actions and behaviors, otherwise, their failure to comply with orders like, "get down on the ground," "get on your knees," or "come over here so I can talk to you" would (rationally) lead you to believe that they are a willfully direct threat.
What to do
If, on your arrival, the subject seems to be in crisis, request additional units to assist. Training communications personnel to recognize the hallmarks of excited delirium can result in an early coordinated medical/law enforcement response.
A person experiencing an excited delirium may have an altered perception of reality; could be very frightened; which may activate the fight or flight response. This person requires medical attention and will likely strenuously resist any efforts to gain control of his or her movements. If not already en route, call for medical assistance as soon as you realize the scope of the situation.
Remember, these subjects are extremely strong and seem to feel no pain. Baton strikes and pepper spray do not have their expected effect. Conducted energy devices (TASER©) can provide a window of opportunity during which officers can establish control and secure the subject’s hands with handcuffs. Secure their legs and roll them into a position where they can cause themselves the least harm. Subjects in excited delirium are known to bang their face and head against the ground or nearby objects. Rolling them onto their side and placing an emergency blanket under their head should limit the subject’s injuries. Again, get them to a hospital as soon as possible.
Consider the Thomas Theorem when interacting with persons who have a mental illness. Their perceptions are as real to them as your reality is to you.
Local experts on how to respond to someone experiencing an acute mental health crisis are nurses within your community skilled in caring for mentally ill patients. They can be a great resource for you and they will likely have lots of examples for you to consider.I continue to recommend two recent texts on excited delirium (Di Maio & Di Maio, 2005; Ross & Chan, 2006). The Di Maio book includes a chapter that deals with how law enforcement officers might handle an excited delirium case.
An outstanding program on mental illness and the associated difficulties some people live with is FRONTLINE’s “The New Asylums.” This award winning program can be viewed on-line at http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/asylums/view/. While the information comes from a correctional setting, I found valuable links to front-line response issues. As you watch the program keep the Thomas Theorem in mind. Appreciating the difference between your perception of reality and the perceived reality of people the inmates represent will benefit you and your community. Remember, everyone belongs to someone.
NOTE: I wish to thank Dr. Ivanhoe Becker MB.ChB., CCFP, for his guidance and assistance in reviewing this paper.
The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the opinions or policies of the Ontario Police College or the Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services.
- Di Maio, V. J. M., & Di Maio, T. G. (2005). Excited delirium syndrome: Cause of death and prevention. Baca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
- Howard, R. (Writer) (2001). A beautiful mind [Film]. In B. Grazer & R. Howard (Producer). USA: Universal Pictures.
- Ross, D. L., & Chan, T. (Eds.). (2006). Sudden deaths in custody. Totowa, NJ: Humana Press.
- Spielberg, S. (Writer) (1981). Raiders of the lost ark [Film]. In F. Marshall (Producer). USA: Paramount Pictures.
- Thomas, W. I., & Thomas, D. S. (1928). The child in America: Behavioral problems and programs. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, Inc.
- EMS Training