Field studies: Great, but not last word

Helicopter study brings up several good points about EMS transport methods and research in general

Editor’s Note:

Editor's note: A few medical directors weigh in on a study that says trauma patients transported by air have a 16 percent improved chance of survival.

Debate has raged fast and furious about the efficacy of helicopter transport for trauma patients. Given the crash rate for medevacs through the years, it is important to justify the risk of flying critically injured patients to trauma centers in return for better outcomes.

The study referred to here brings up several good points about EMS transport methods and research in general.

First, being published in the Journal of the American Medical Association is a prestigious accomplishment and infers that the study was closely controlled and reviewed. In other words, it's a good study, based on the parameters the researchers specified.

In addition, the researchers looked at previous studies on the topic and improved upon them in terms of research techniques and controlling for "confounders" — issues that could inaccurately skew the results. This is the value of having multiple studies looking at the same core topic.

Also, the study contained a lot of patient records. Bigger numbers usually mean more accurate and more generalizable results.

Finally, while a study of past patient records is not the same as a prospective, randomly controlled study, the researchers clearly pointed out how difficult it would be to conduct such a study. Simply getting permission from patients and communities would be daunting, not to mention potentially unethical.

As both the physicians in the article as well as the researchers in the study point out, you can't just accept the conclusions blindly, nor can you assume that they absolutely apply to your own region.

Other factors beyond the study must be taken into account. Yet the data is compelling and adds another piece to the puzzle of determining best approaches to EMS field care.

About the author

Art Hsieh, MA, NRP teaches in Northern California at the Public Safety Training Center, Santa Rosa Junior College in the Emergency Care Program. An EMS provider since 1982, Art has served as a line medic, supervisor and chief officer in the private, third service and fire-based EMS. He has directed both primary and EMS continuing education programs. Art is a textbook writer, author of "EMT Exam for Dummies," has presented at conferences nationwide and continues to provide direct patient care regularly. Art is a member of the EMS1 Editorial Advisory Board. Contact Art at and connect with him on Facebook or Twitter.

Recommended for you

Join the discussion

logo for print